At 34–35 Maiden Lane in London’s Covent Garden, a restaurant has kept welcoming diners since 1798. The building and a collection tied to its history now have a new steward: owner J-P Mayhew has given the property and historic objects to the National Trust. Rules will continue operating at the address as an independent restaurant, with its business owned by longtime proprietor Ricky McMenemy.
The National Trust announced the gift on Oct. 14. The organization says the annual rent from the restaurant’s tenancy will provide income for conservation work. The arrangement separates two things that can easily be blurred together in a headline: the Trust will care for the historic building and collection, while the restaurant business remains McMenemy’s and continues to serve customers.
That distinction matters because Rules is not being turned into a Trust-run restaurant or a museum. The Trust’s own visitor information says the restaurant is operated by a third-party commercial tenant. In its announcement, it said McMenemy, who has worked at Rules for 35 years, would become its tenant after the gift. It also described the site as the first building in its care to house a historic restaurant that remains in operation.
The place’s long run began as an oyster house. The National Trust says Thomas Rule opened it in 1798, and Rules is widely recognized as London’s oldest restaurant. Its address has remained a restaurant for more than two centuries, even as the city around Covent Garden changed. That continuous use gives the property a different kind of heritage: it is part of the city’s past, but still a place people enter for an ordinary meal.
The National Trust describes the interiors as Grade II-listed and says they reflect more than 200 years of continuous dining history. It also says Rules maintained a tradition of English country-house cuisine from the 19th century and continued through World War II and rationing. Those details help explain why the gift includes both architecture and objects: preservation here is about a place that has kept serving people, and the records of how that life looked over time.
The gift includes more than the walls and interior. The National Trust lists visitor books, menus, caricatures, photographs, stained glass and signs among the collection. Together, those objects preserve traces of how the restaurant looked and how people used it across generations. Rather than relying only on a written timeline, the collection holds menus, images and records produced as the restaurant’s life unfolded.
The separation between property and business began before this week’s announcement. The Guardian reported on Oct. 13 that Mayhew had sold the restaurant business to McMenemy in 2022, while retaining the historic home. The National Trust’s Oct. 14 release confirms the present arrangement: McMenemy owns the restaurant business and becomes the commercial tenant of the property. The gift therefore secures a building and collection without transferring day-to-day restaurant ownership to the charity.
Mayhew’s gift answers a preservation question that can face historic places still in active use: who will care for the structure and its records while the business inside carries on? The National Trust says it will protect the building and collection and use charitable income from rent to support conservation. Its release also says the restaurant will continue operating. Those are specific commitments about stewardship and continued use; they do not mean the Trust will run the restaurant or guarantee that every detail of its business will remain unchanged.
For Londoners and visitors, the result is a working historic place rather than a sealed display. The Trust says 34–35 Maiden Lane is a rare example where the building and its original use remain linked. Its visitor page identifies the restaurant as operated by a third-party tenant and directs table bookings to Rules. The restaurant’s continued operation keeps its history connected to the setting that produced it, while the collection gives the Trust material to preserve and share.
A historic restaurant depends on people continuing to use it, not only on its age. Rules’ building, collection and independent business now have distinct roles in the arrangement: the National Trust cares for the property, the collection is protected alongside it, and McMenemy’s restaurant continues as tenant. The gesture gives a familiar Covent Garden address a conservation plan while leaving its doors open for the work it has done for more than two centuries: welcoming diners.
Reader responses